“Why Not” Indeed …
Sunday, January 22nd, 2006
I’m mad at ABC for cancelling the new Heather Graham sitcom, “Emily’s Reasons Why Not”.
No, I wasn’t a fan of the show; I never saw it, and there was nothing about the commercials that made me want to tune in. And no, I’m not a huge fan of Heather Graham.
So why am I rallying to the defense of a show I don’t care about?
Because it’s the principle of the thing, and not caring about the show makes this the perfect time to complain on principle.
I’m complaining because they cancelled the show after showing only one episode. They spent millions of dollars producing and advertising the show, then they yank it after the first sign of a weak response.
That’s been a disturbing trend in the last few years, and it’s puzzlingly self-destructive. There are lots of great shows that didn’t hit their stride until after their first season.
The Simpsons is a prime example: Sure, their first season was better than most assembly-line network garbage, but it was a pale comparison to its golden age of Seasons Four and Five. Other shows that still hadn’t found their way early on include Barney Miller, Seinfeld, Star Trek: The Next Generation, and Roseanne, all of which went on to become classics. If today’s itchy-trigger-finger network morons had been in charge, these shows would have just been footnotes in old TV-show directories.
I’m not saying “Emily’s” had the makings of a classic, but now we’ll never know.
Is it really good business to spend all this money on a series and not use it? Seeing how dismal the ratings have been for all the networks have been lately, has this on-going gamble — that the replacement show’s ratings will be so much better as to make up for the wasted money of the abandoned series — really been paying off?
And here’s another example of network stupidity: “Emily’s” was part of ABC’s genius plan to replace Monday Night Football with romantic sitcoms.
Um … excuse me? If you’ve got lots of men tuning in at a certain day and time for thirty-six years, wouldn’t it make sense to program something that the people who are already in the habit of tuning in would want to watch?? Is it smart to replace the old show with a show for which you have to attract a whole different viewing audience??
Sure, give Heather a girly comedy, but put it somewhere else on the schedule.
Is it really that freaking difficult???
We rented
A good thing about having a blog is that I can make a note of when things happen, so I can have it for later reference.

